COURT UPHOLDS ARBITRATOR’S DECISION REGARDING CLASS CERTIFICATION
Sutter, a New Jersey pediatrician, filed a class action complaint against Oxford and several other health insurers for failure to pay medical claims timely and correctly under New Jersey law. Shortly after the case was filed, a New Jersey court granted Oxford’s motion to compel arbitration. Arbitration proceeded under the rules of the American Arbitration Association, which included a specific rule governing class actions. In 2005, the sole arbitrator issued a partial final class determination award, where he defined the class of claimants and certified the class. Oxford promptly filed a motion in district court to vacate the award. The District Court upheld the award, rejecting defendant’s argument that the arbitrator exceeded his authority and manifestly disregarded the law. The Third Circuit recently affirmed the judgment, finding that the arbitrator had not acted in manifest disregard of law, because he had considered all of the requirements set forth in the AAA's class action rule. Sutter v. Oxford Health Plans, Case No. 05-5223 (3rd Cir. February 28, 2007)
